Benny's Pizza & Italian Restaurant Menu
Welcome to Benny's Pizza & Italian Restaurant, a hidden gem located at 1910 Lincoln Way E, Guilford, PA. This charming eatery has garnered rave reviews from satisfied customers, praising its incredible food and welcoming atmosphere.
- Delicious Offerings: Benny's menu features an array of mouth-watering pizzas, subs, and Italian dishes that leave patrons coming back for more.
- Fresh Ingredients: Reviewers consistently note the freshness of the ingredients, which elevates each dish. Customers rave about the flavor and quality of every meal.
- Friendly Service: The attentive and friendly staff ensure a delightful dining experience, making guests feel right at home.
Whether you're stopping by for a quick meal or a sit-down dinner, Benny's has something to satisfy every palate. Highly recommended for families and travelers alike, it’s no wonder this spot has quickly become a favorite in the area!
NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA
SPECIALTY PIZZAS
CALZONE
STROMBOLI
HOT SUBS
COLD SUBS
PANINIS
WRAPS
APPETIZERS
SANDWICHES
CHILDREN’S MENU
DESSERT
SIDES
BEVERAGES
FRESH SALADS
ENTREES
SPAGHETTI YOUR WAY
SPECIALS
NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA
Small cheese pizza
US$10.79
Medium pizza
US$11.00
Large cheese
US$12.49
Small deluxe pizza
US$13.50
Medium deluxe pizza
US$15.59
Large deluxe pizza
US$17.99
Small vegetable pizza
US$13.50
Medium vegetable pizza
US$14.99
Large vegetable pizza
US$17.49
Small Bianca pizza
US$13.59
Medium Bianca pizza
US$14.59
Large Bianca pizza
US$17.29
Siciliana pizza
US$15.89
Deluxe Sicilian pizza
US$18.89
Small Pizza di mare
US$13.99
Medium pizza di mare
US$15.99
Large pizza di mare
US$18.89
Small BBQ chicken pizza
US$13.50
Medium BBQ chicken pizza
US$15.19
Large BBQ chicken
US$17.59
Small pizza margherite
US$12.99
Medium margherite pizza
US$14.29
Large margherite pizza
US$17.69
Small Greek pizza
US$13.59
Medium Greek pizza
US$14.59
Large Greek pizza
US$17.59
Small meat lovers pizza
US$13.49
Medium meat lovers pizza
US$14.59
Large meat lovers pizza
US$18.49
Small cheese lovers pizza
US$12.99
Medium cheese lover pizza
US$14.19
Large cheese lovers pizza
US$17.29
Small taco pizza
US$13.59
Medium taco pizza
US$15.59
Large taco pizza
US$17.89
Small Buffalo chicken pizza
US$13.49
Medium buffalo chicken pizza
US$14.59
Large buffalo chicken
US$17.59
Small chicken bacon ranch
US$13.49
Medium chicken bacon ranch pizza
US$14.59
Large chicken bacon ranch pizza
US$17.89
Small steak pizza
US$13.59
Medium steak pizza
US$15.59
Large steak pizza
US$17.99
SPECIALTY PIZZAS
CALZONE
Small Italian calzone
US$12.50
Large Italian calzone
US$15.99
Small chicken broccoli calzone
US$12.50
Large chicken broccoli calzone
US$15.29
Small Chicken calzone
US$12.99
Large chicken calzone
US$15.99
Small meat lovers calzone
US$13.19
Large meat lovers calzone
US$15.79
Small veggie calzone
US$12.69
Large veggie calzone
US$14.99
Small ham calzone
US$12.99
Large ham calzone
US$15.19
Small Regular Stromboli
US$12.89
Large regular Stromboli
US$15.89
Small deluxe Stromboli
US$13.59
Large deluxe Stromboli
US$16.19
Small vegetarian Stromboli
US$12.99
Large vegetarian Stromboli
US$16.16
Small ham and cheese Stromboli
US$11.99
Large ham and cheese Stromboli
US$14.59
Small steak Stromboli
US$12.89
Large steak Stromboli
US$16.19
Small chicken Stromboli
US$12.99
Large chicken Stromboli
US$16.19
STROMBOLI
HOT SUBS
Small steak and cheese
US$7.59
Large steak and cheese
US$10.29
Small Philly cheese steak
US$7.59
Large Philly cheese steak
US$10.29
Small ultimate cheese steak
US$7.59
Large ultimate cheese steak
US$10.29
Small pizza steak
US$7.59
Large pizza steak
US$10.29
Small chicken cheese steak
US$7.59
Large chicken cheese steak
US$10.29
Small grilled chicken steak deluxe
US$7.59
Large grilled chicken steak deluxe
US$10.29
Small chicken ranch
US$7.59
Large chicken ranch sub
US$10.29
Small cheeseburger sub
US$7.59
Large cheese burger sub
US$10.29
Small pizza burger
US$7.59
Large pizza burger sub
US$10.29
Small sausage sub
US$7.59
Large sausage sub
US$10.29
Small vegetarian sub
US$7.59
Large vegetarian sub
US$10.29
Small Benny’s bomb
US$7.59
Large Benny’s bomb
US$10.59
Small bacon cheeseburger sub
US$7.59
Large bacon cheeseburger
US$10.29
Small meat balls sub
US$7.59
Large meat balls sub
US$10.29
Small toasted turkey boat
US$7.59
Large toasted turkey boat
US$10.29
Small toasted ham boat
US$7.59
Large toasted ham boat
US$10.29
Small Chicken parm sub
US$7.59
Large chicken parm sub
US$10.29
Small eggplant parm sub
US$7.59
Large eggplant parm sub
US$10.29
Small BLT
US$7.59
Large BLT sub
US$10.29
Small Turkey and provolone cheese sub
US$7.59
Large turkey and provolone cheese
US$10.29
Small capicola and provolone cheese
US$7.59
Large capicola and provolone cheese
US$10.29
Small provolone cheese
US$7.50
Large provolone sub
US$9.99
Small salami and provolone
US$7.59
Large salami and provolone
US$7.50
Small special sub
US$7.59
Large special sub
US$9.99
Small Italian cold cut
US$7.50
Large Italian cold cut
US$9.99
COLD SUBS
PANINIS
Turkey club
US$10.00
Italiano
US$10.00
Caprese
US$10.00
Turkey
US$10.00
New Stule
US$10.00
BBQ Chicken
US$10.00
Leave it to us
US$10.00
Chicken pesto panini
US$10.00
Ham Panini
US$10.00
Chicken panini
US$10.00
Chicken chipotle
US$10.00
Chicken Caesar wrap
US$9.50
Ham and cheese wrap
US$9.50
Turkey wrap
US$9.50
Tuna wraps
US$9.50
Cheese steak wrap
US$9.99
Chicken ranch wrap
US$9.50
Buffalo chicken wrap
US$9.50
Grilled chicken wraps
US$9.50
Fried chicken wrap
US$9.50
WRAPS
APPETIZERS
Calamari rings
US$8.99
Jalapeno poppers
US$7.50
Butterfly shrimp
US$9.50
Basket sampler
US$9.00
Onion Rings
US$6.29
Bacon cheese fries
US$7.99
Meatballs
US$7.99
Breaded mushrooms
US$7.00
Chicken tenders
US$6.99
Chicken nuggets
US$6.19
Pizza fries
US$6.99
Mozzarella sticks
US$7.00
Fried Zucchini
US$7.00
Garlic Knots
US$6.50
Cheese bread sticks
US$6.50
Garlic Bread
US$3.19
Fried pickles
US$7.19
French Fries
US$3.59
Pepperoni Rolls
US$8.59
Cheeseburger
US$8.49
Ham and cheese sandwich
US$7.99
Fish sandwich
US$8.19
Grilled cheese sandwich
US$7.59
Fried chicken sandwich
US$8.19
Grilled chicken sandwich
US$8.49
Ranch Chicken Sandwich
US$8.49
Double cheeseburger Special
US$8.49
Gyro
US$8.19
SANDWICHES
CHILDREN’S MENU
Quesadilla
US$7.19
Cheeseburger
US$7.99
Lasagna
US$7.29
Grilled cheese
US$7.59
Spaghetti
US$6.99
Chicken nuggets
US$6.99
Bambino cheese pizza
US$8.99
Chicken tenders French Fries
US$7.50
Cannoli
US$4.50
Cheese cake
US$4.29
Donuts
US$3.99
Tiramisu
US$4.99
Funnel cake fries
US$6.29
Lemon Italian cream cake
US$4.99
DESSERT
SIDES
Homemade chips
US$4.00
French fries
US$3.69
Curly fries
US$4.89
fountain drinks
US$1.69
20 oz bottles
US$1.99
2 liter bottles
US$2.99
Sweet or unsweetened
US$1.99
BEVERAGES
FRESH SALADS
Mediterranean chicken salad
US$9.59
Buffalo chicken salad
US$9.50
Antipasto salad
US$10.19
Caesar salad
US$7.99
Chicken Caesar salad
US$9.19
Chef salad
US$9.99
Agean salad
US$9.29
Taco salad
US$9.59
Tuna salad
US$8.99
Shrimp salad
US$9.99
Toaster salad
US$6.99
Side salad
US$3.99
Avocado salad
US$10.19
Harvest salad
US$9.99
Chicken or veal parmigiana
US$13.99
Florentine chicken or veal
US$13.99
Pollo alla vodka
US$13.99
Chicken Marsala
US$13.99
Chicken Picatta
US$13.99
Chicken broccoli fettuccine Alfredo
US$14.19
Shrimp Parmagiana
US$14.59
Shrimp scampi
US$14.59
Shrimp marinara
US$14.59
Crab and salmon Alfredo
US$15.59
Crab and shrimp Alfredo
US$15.59
Gamberi carciori
US$14.59
Pesto pasta
US$13.99
Cheese tortellini
US$13.19
Shrimp fettuccine Alfredo
US$14.59
Spinach ravioli
US$12.99
Pasta carbonara
US$13.99
Baked Citi
US$13.19
Stuffed shells
US$13.00
Lasagna
US$12.99
Meat ravioli
US$12.59
Eggplant parmigiana
US$13.59
Fettuccine Alfredo
US$12.99
Sausage, peppers and mushrooms
US$13.99
Chicken cacciatore
US$13.49
Benny’s trio
US$13.99
Tour of Italy
US$13.99
ENTREES
SPAGHETTI YOUR WAY
Spaghetti Mushrooms sauce
US$13.59
Spaghetti, fresh garlic and olives oil
US$12.59
Spaghetti meatballs
US$13.99
Spaghetti with clam sauce
US$13.99
Spaghetti with tomato sauce
US$12.19
Spaghetti with meatballs and sausage
US$14.19
Spaghetti sausage
US$13.99
Spaghetti Alfredo sauce and clam
US$14.50
Pesto sauce
US$13.99
Pink sauce
US$13.19
Spaghetti Meat sauce
US$13.29
Personal sized pizza 1 topping
US$8.99
2 large pizzas one topping and a 2 liter
US$24.99
2 large cheese pizza
US$20.99
2 large cheese(10) wings and and a 2 liter
US$30.99
1 large cheese(10) wings and a 2 liter
US$21.99
Medium cheese pizza 1 large any sub
US$19.19
Large any subs and a side of French
US$12.59
Small any subs/French fries/drinks
US$9.59